In June 2022, BBC Panorama broadcast an undercover investigation into an NHS GP practice run by a private company. It reported a shortage of GPs, less qualified staff working without adequate supervision and a backlog of patient paperwork. We look at what it found, what has changed since and what choices you have if you want to see a GP sooner.
What Panorama found in 2022
The programme, broadcast on 13 June 2022, featured journalist Jacqui Wakefield, who worked undercover as a receptionist at a London GP practice run by Operose Health. At the time, Operose was a private company that ran 70 GP practices across England for almost 600,000 NHS patients, which made it the largest supplier of GP services to the NHS. Panorama looked at appointments, patient care, staffing and the handling of patient documents.
Appointments and patient care
Jacqui Wakefield worked at the practice for six weeks and described what she saw in her undercover diary for BBC News. On one day in May 2022, no doctor or physician associate was available to see patients with appointments, and calls piled up, from 40 at 8am to dozens more soon after. That week, there wasn’t a single day with more than two full-time doctors available for appointments at a practice with 20,000 patients, and some patients were calling every day, sometimes several times.
One patient complained that he could never see his named GP, who was also the GP director. Other staff had told the reporter that this doctor came in rarely, but she was told never to tell patients that he wasn’t at the practice or available, and was told he was “always here” because he could be reached by phone.
Use of physician associates
The programme also found that the practice used physician associates (PAs) in place of GPs. PAs are healthcare professionals who have completed two years of postgraduate study on top of a science degree, compared with about 10 years of education and training for a GP. The practice manager said the practice hired PAs because they were “cheaper” than GPs. Since December 2024, PAs have been regulated by the General Medical Council. In July 2025, the Government accepted a review’s recommendation that they should in future be called physician assistants, and it consulted on the change of title in 2026.
The PAs told the undercover reporter that they saw all sorts of patients, sometimes without any clinical supervision, and that the practice treated them as equivalent to GPs. A locum GP at the practice told her that PAs aren’t the same as GPs and need help and supervision. He said he had asked for time in his daily shifts to talk through cases and support the PAs’ clinical lead, but management refused. Operose said a clinical lead was on site most of the time to help answer PAs’ questions.
How patient documents were handled
The undercover reporter also spoke to the admin team, who processed patient correspondence and passed it to GPs. This central team handled documents for about 30 Operose GP practices. Its role was to decide whether each document needed to be seen by a GP or a pharmacist, or filed in a patient’s medical records. The documents included test results, hospital letters and medication changes. One worker said they had to get through 200 documents a day, and one member of staff, worried about making mistakes, said they sometimes used Google to help work out what to do with the documents.
Staff also said some correspondence had been waiting to be seen by a GP or pharmacist for up to six months.
What a senior GP made of the footage
Panorama showed its footage to Professor Sir Sam Everington, a senior practising GP at a partner-run practice unconnected with Operose. He said he was concerned for patient safety. At his own practice, he said, PAs debrief with him every day, discussing every patient they have seen, and he was worried to see PAs at the Operose practice saying they weren’t getting the supervision they needed: “They’re clearly articulating it, but they’re not getting it. And that’s a problem.”
He also said the delay in reviewing documents was unsafe: “If a letter destined for the GP is not being acted on for six months, that is a massive risk to patients, both in terms of the development of a more serious disease and them dying earlier.”
Operose Health’s response
The BBC put the findings to Operose, which said it was not short-staffed and worked in patients’ best interests. It said its clinical systems showed five GPs working at the practice on the day with no appointments, including one providing remote cover, but it didn’t respond when the BBC asked whether patients could book appointments with them. Panorama’s analysis of NHS data found that Operose practices averaged a little over 0.6 full-time equivalent GPs for every 2,000 registered patients, half the NHS average of 1.2, and that Operose employed six times as many PAs as the NHS average. Operose denied being over-reliant on PAs and said its use of them was in line with NHS England’s long-term plan. It said it had recruited 38 GPs in the previous 12 months and was recruiting 14 more, that 97% of its practices were rated “good” or “outstanding” by the Care Quality Commission (CQC), and that its document workflow had been commended by NHS England. The CQC said it takes all concerns seriously and would follow up as appropriate.
Operose has since changed owner. In 2022, it was owned by the US healthcare company Centene Corporation. Companies House records for Operose Health Ltd show that control passed to T20 Osprey Midco Ltd on 28 December 2023, and NHS Nottingham and Nottinghamshire Integrated Care Board has described Osprey Midco as part of HCRG Care Group. Our guide to who owns GP practices in the UK explains how private companies and GP partners run NHS practices.

Pressure on NHS GPs and hospital waiting lists
It’s no secret that the NHS is under pressure. According to the BMA’s analysis of NHS England data, there were 29,400 full-time equivalent fully qualified GPs in England in September 2026, only 36 more than in September 2015, while the number of patients registered with GP practices rose by about 6.1 million to 63 million. Since 2015, 1,485 independent community GP practices in England have closed or merged, leaving 6,138.
Hospital waiting lists are long too. NHS England’s figures for the end of September 2026 show 7.4 million referral to treatment pathways in England waiting to start treatment, which is around 6.2 million patients because some are waiting on more than one pathway. Of those pathways, 65.8% had been waiting up to 18 weeks, against a 92% standard, and 116,353 had been waiting more than 52 weeks. None of these figures shows how many people have tried and failed to get an appointment with their GP.
Could a private GP help if you can afford it?
It could, if you can afford it and your needs are straightforward. If you’ve struggled to get an appointment with your GP, it may not just be a lack of availability: many surgeries are open mainly during standard working hours, which can be hard to fit around work. In England, the NHS also offers some evening and Saturday appointments, which may be at another local surgery or NHS service rather than your own, and some NHS GPs offer video consultations. You can also pay for a private appointment as and when you need one.
Many private health insurance policies include a virtual GP service, with phone or video appointments at any time of day. It won’t be the right choice if you have a complex medical condition or need ongoing management of a chronic disease, but it could suit you if you need quick advice or treatment for a straightforward illness. If you’d like to see whether health insurance would cover future medical expenses, including a virtual GP, you can get comparison quotes through myTribe from the UK’s leading insurers. Cover is for future medical conditions, so conditions you already have usually aren’t covered at first.

