Seven questions to ask your health insurance broker
Finding the right health insurance can feel like navigating a maze. A health insurance broker can help you compare quotes and understand your options, but how do you find the right one? Here are seven questions to ask that can help you choose your broker.
Questions to help you find the right health insurance broker
There’s more than one kind of insurance broker, and some work across many kinds of insurance while others focus on health insurance. A broker that focuses on health insurance is likely to know the market and the cover available in more depth, which can help you find a policy that suits your needs.
A broker works with a number of health insurance companies, and a good one can explain how your choices affect your health insurance costs, cover and experience when you claim. Here are some questions that a health insurance broker should be able to answer to help you make an informed choice.
1. Which insurers does the broker have access to?
A good broker can quote you from a range of insurers. Before you buy, a broker must tell you whether it gives a personal recommendation on the basis of a fair and personal analysis of the market or works with a set list of insurers, and in that case it must name the insurers.
Some brokers have a restricted panel of insurance providers, so they can only introduce you to the ones they’re authorised to sell. While you should still be able to compare different quotes, you will get less choice than with a broker that analyses the market fairly. It’s also important to watch out for advisers who are agents rather than brokers. An agent is tied to an insurer, usually just one, so they can only introduce you to that insurer’s policies.
The more insurers a broker can quote from, the more choice you have and the better your chance of finding cover that suits you.
Related articles
- What is an insurance broker?
How brokers work, how they are paid and what to look for in one.
- Why an experienced health insurance broker is worth their weight in gold
How much experience matters when you choose a broker.
- Best private health insurance in the UK for 2026: myTribe’s top 10 providers
How the leading UK insurers compare on cover, limits and customer reviews, with our expert ratings.
2. Can I come back to the broker if I need help with my policy?
Brokers differ in how much support they give after you buy, so ask what yours offers. A broker will help you find the right policy, and some can also be a source of support when needed. Everyone is different, and the level of help and advice you need will be personal to you. The service your broker offers can vary depending on your needs and the type of policy you have. Typically, a business with a group policy will likely need more support than an individual who claims infrequently.
Asking your broker to answer questions about the type of support they offer can help you decide whether they’re the right choice for you. Some brokers will be on hand to answer questions about your policy coverage. Others may be able to guide you through the process when you claim on your health insurance plan.
Think about the level of support you may need so you can ask the right questions when you talk to a health insurance broker.
3. Will the broker review my policy each year?
Some brokers review your policy at each renewal and some don’t, so ask whether yours will. Your insurer assesses the premium you pay for your health insurance based on various factors, including your age, where you live and whether you smoke.
When your health insurance plan comes up for renewal each year, the price will usually go up, because treatment costs rise each year and you are a year older. It’s vital you understand whether your broker will review your renewal quote and check that the cover still meets your needs.
Changing circumstances can mean a different health insurance plan or a new provider would be better for you. Switching can be complex, and having a broker support you can simplify the process.
Compare health insurance quotes
See what cover from the UK’s leading insurers would cost for your age and needs.
4. Is it worth going for full medical underwriting?
Full medical underwriting is worth considering if you want to know what is covered and excluded before the policy starts, while moratorium underwriting is quicker to set up. Underwriting can be complex, so it’s worth finding a broker who can explain it clearly. There are two main types of underwriting on individual health insurance policies.
If you have moratorium underwriting, you won’t need to provide any medical information when you take out the policy. Conditions you’ve had symptoms of, advice about or treatment for in the previous five years (three years with some insurers) aren’t covered at first, and they can become eligible for cover if you go two continuous years after the policy starts without symptoms, treatment, medication or advice for them. When you choose full medical underwriting, you’ll be asked to complete a medical questionnaire, and the insurer then tells you which conditions it excludes.
The advantage of full medical underwriting is that you’ll know what is covered and excluded from the outset, so you’re less likely to be surprised by a declined claim. The claims process can also be quicker than with moratorium underwriting, as your insurer won’t need to check your medical history when you claim. Prices can differ between the two types, so compare quotes for both.
5. What are the pros and cons of a guided consultant list?
The main advantage of a guided consultant list is a lower premium, and the main drawback is less choice of who treats you. Most health insurance gives you a lot of choice about which consultant you see or which hospital you attend, but with a guided consultant list some insurers offer a choice of only two or three consultants, and some policies only pay for treatment with a specialist the insurer has found for you. Our research found that policies with a guided consultant option are around 16% cheaper on average than those with unrestricted access, which could let you afford more cover. It suits you if you’re happy to take your insurer’s advice about which doctors you see.
A guided list isn’t for everyone: if you want to see a particular consultant because they offer a specific type of treatment, because you’ve had a personal recommendation or because you’ve already seen them via the NHS, they may not be available on it. Ask how the insurer picks its shortlist before you choose this option.
6. What are the major exclusions from my health insurance policy?
The major exclusions on a health insurance policy are standard ones that apply to every policy, such as cosmetic surgery and chronic conditions, and others that depend on your medical history. Your broker won’t be able to advise you on the exclusions specific to you when you get in touch to request a comparison quote. However, they should explain what you can expect from the process. As we’ve already mentioned, the process is different depending on your underwriting type. Your insurer will only confirm any exclusions when you’ve provided medical information or after you claim.
On the other hand, your broker should explain which standard exclusions apply to your policy when they help you to compare quotes. You’ll typically find that your medical insurance won’t cover things like cosmetic surgery, straightforward pregnancy and birth, and addiction treatment. Some insurers have a longer list of exclusions but may offer more comprehensive cover elsewhere. Understanding what isn’t covered helps you to choose the right cover for your needs.
Health insurance plans cover treatment for acute conditions, so they don’t usually pay for the treatment or monitoring of chronic conditions, such as diabetes or high blood pressure.
Compare health insurance providers
Compare the UK’s leading health insurance providers and join thousands who have found the right cover with myTribe.
7. Does the broker charge for their service?
Most health insurance brokers are paid commission by the insurer rather than charging you directly, but some also charge a fee. The commission is included in the premium, so you usually pay nothing extra for the broker’s help, and brokers must tell you how they are paid. If a fee is payable, the broker must tell you the amount before you agree to pay it or buy the policy, so ask upfront. Our guide to broker costs explains more.
Brokers form relationships with insurers while still having to act in your best interests. This may let you benefit from lower prices or perks that aren’t offered when you buy direct.
Your broker should be authorised by the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) or be an appointed representative of a firm that is, and FCA rules say a firm must act honestly, fairly and professionally in the best interests of its customer. You can check a firm on the FCA Firm Checker or Financial Services Register before you use it.
Compare health insurance with myTribe
You can compare health insurance quotes through myTribe, and this guide should help you decide what to ask a broker. Our guides are general information, not personal advice, so speaking to a broker can help you choose cover that suits your circumstances and needs.
When you contact us for a comparison quote, we’ll introduce you to one of our FCA-regulated partner brokers, who we vet and monitor.
Frequently Asked Questions
What’s the difference between a health insurance broker and an agent?
An agent is tied to an insurer, usually just one, so they can only offer that insurer’s policies, while a broker can advise you on policies from a range of insurers. Some brokers give a fair and personal analysis of the market, while others work with a set list of insurers, and they must tell you which applies before you buy.
What support can a health insurance broker provide?
Health insurance brokers will help you to compare quotes when you’re first looking for a policy. Some provide support if you have questions about your coverage or when you need to claim on the policy. Your broker may also review your policy when it comes up for renewal to check that it still suits you.
Do health insurance brokers charge a fee?
Most health insurance brokers are paid commission by the insurer, which is included in the premium, so you usually pay nothing extra for their help. Some brokers also charge a fee, and FCA rules say the broker must tell you the amount before you agree to pay it or buy the policy.
How can I check that an insurance broker is regulated?
You can check the firm on the Financial Conduct Authority’s Firm Checker or Financial Services Register, which shows whether it is authorised and has permission for the service it offers, or is an appointed representative of an authorised firm. If you use a firm that isn’t authorised, you won’t have access to the Financial Ombudsman Service or protection from the Financial Services Compensation Scheme.
More questions? Search our site to find the answers
Disclaimer: This is general information, not personal advice. Speak to a qualified broker before making a decision. Our broker partners compare policies from a panel of leading UK insurers, but not all insurers may be available.



